Arc welding vs. gas welding: the bottom line

Welding is one of the basic processes that form the entire construction and manufacturing, automotive, and aerospace applications. It simply fuses two or more pieces made from metal together with the help of heat and pressure that sometimes collaborate with each other. Of all the various techniques offered, two welding techniques—the most used—arc welding and gas welding. The two techniques differ with advantages and disadvantages, different applications, and utility. This article represents significant differences between arc welding and gas welding in terms of methods, equipment, materials, safety issues, and the best cases of usage.

Introduction to Welding

I have to take a step back and discuss some basics involving welding itself before getting into an overview of arc welding vs. gas welding. More generally, welding is a process through which two distinct pieces of metal are joined by means of heat. In some welds, there will be some filler material going into the weld, and other welds involve the melting of metals together to make the weld. The welding type would call for variations in the applied specific techniques based on other factors to be combined, such as sources of heat, techniques, or equipment.

Two techniques are primarily used in joining a metal: arc and gas welding. They vary in terms of the source of heat, the application process, and the ideal projects.

What is arc welding?

Arc welding, or electric arc welding, uses an electric arc to generate heat needed in the melting of the metal. It starts with the electrode, whereby first the electric arc forms on the anode and workpiece.

It could be consumable wire or non-consumable rod depending on the type of arc welding.

Types of arc welding

There are so many types of welds that exist these days, but amongst the most basic types, there are the following:

Shielded Metal Arc Welding (SMAW): It is sometimes also termed stick welding. In this technique, an electrode consumable is used that is coated with flux. It guards the melt pool from air that exists around it and therefore wards off contamination.
Gas Metal Arc Welding, or GMAW: This is also more simply called MIG, or metal-inert gas welding. It is carried out by a continuously fed wire electrode covered by a flow of inert gas. Argon-gas is most commonly used to shield the weld pool.
Tungsten inert gas welding or TIG welding: This process uses an inert-gas shielded coreless arc having a non-consumed and therefore not eroded by the welding action-tungsten electrode coupled with an external filler rod. With this shielding, it provides very strict control of the weld pool, which is very vital to quality welds in thin metal.

What is gas welding?

It is an oxyacetylene welding process in oxy-fuel welding or gas welding. This is pretty explanatory in nature; it is a type of process wherein heat to melt the base metal is supplied by the combustion of fuel gas that is a mix of oxygen and acetylene. In most cases, filler metal is added so as to form a successful joint. Except for welding, gas welding can be used for cutting, brazing, or soldering. This was the most conventionally applied form of welding at that time, and arc welding techniques had not yet been discovered.

Flame Control: the welder controls the size and temperature of the flame.
Mobility: Gas welding equipment is relatively mobile because they do not need electricity; only fuel gas tanks are needed.
Versatility: Besides welding, a gas torch could be utilised for heating, cutting, and brazing.

Which of these two is the largest difference: arc welding vs. gas welding?

Source of Heat

Arc Welding: It generates very high-intensity heat between the electrode and workpiece. It is as hot as 3,600 degrees Celsius or 6,500 degrees Fahrenheit. For welds, the thickness can be applied.
Gas Welding: This is carried out by a flame generated through combustion of oxygen and fuel gas (acetylene). The temperature which such a flame can achieve depends on the type of gas applied, though it can reach as high as about 5,000°F or 2,760°C. The temperature achieved in flames for gas welding is less than that achieved during arc welding, and thus, this process is also less versatile for thicker materials.

Welding process

Arc Welding: In arc welding, the electric current travels through an electrode that generates the arc as well as the melting of the electrode as well as the base material. Sometimes, this process requires a power source and special electrodes. A few arcs use a filler rod, while others are consumable electrodes, like SMAW stick welding.
Gas Welding: In gas welding, the torch has two parts: the oxygen and a fuel gas, which lights itself, and the flame is focused onto the joint in order to melt the metal. The welder often makes use of a filler rod to fill the joint.

Equipment and Mobility

Arc welding equipment: The main contrast with gas welding is that arc welding requires much more equipment. Some of the pieces of equipment used include an AC or DC power supply, an electrode holder, a welding helmet, gloves, and protective clothing. There are portable arc welding machines; however, the overall setup tends to be much less portable.
Gas welding equipment: Gas welding is much more portable. The important equipment includes a gas torch, supply of oxygen and fuel gas (stowed normally in separate cylinders), and safety equipment. Gas welding equipment does not rely on electricity so that it may be operated wherever electricity availability is not possible, thereby making it ideal for outdoor or field work.

Welding Speed and Efficiency

Arc welding: In arc welding, processes are relatively much faster compared to gas welding, especially when the processes are likely to be MIG and TIG welding. MIG welding involves a continuously feeding wire, providing welds at speeds of high rates with the least possible stoppages.
Gas Welding: Gas welding is slower as compared to arc welding due to the manual manipulation of the flame and relatively lower output of heat. It's more time-consuming; the welder has to constantly adjust the flame so as to achieve the right temperature to be used in welding the joint.

Equipment and Consumables Cost

Arc Welding: Arc welds come with huge investment in terms of machinery. In fact, initial high investment is expected when it comes to heavy-duty machines of industrial grade. True to that is that consumables like electrodes and filler rods do add some weight to the cost, but this depends on the kind of welding being used.
Gas welding: It is relatively costly as compared to this gas welding equipment, and the consumables oxygen and acetylene tend to be relatively cheaper than the electrodes in the case of arc welding. However, it is not productive at other times as it takes a considerable amount of time for the completion of welding, hence it is not economically viable for large projects.

Safety Issues

Arc Welding: All the products of arc welding contain dangerous temperatures and ultraviolet light that can be harmful or even burn the eyes if safety measures are not designed. So, protective gear is a must, especially helmets, gloves, and flame-resistant clothing when one is welding.
Gas Welding: Similarly, gas welding also carries some risks, but the risks involved are those very volatile gases that are used in the process. Ventilation is needed to remove the accumulation of inflammable gases. Protection of clothes and eye- coverings can keep no burns or eye injuries.

Conclusion

While arc welding has more disadvantages and advantages than many of the others, it is in most cases faster and more efficient as well. That makes it ideal for bigger projects and much stronger materials but can't be used on any kind of metal since it is very versatile compared with this. Much more complex equipment and safety measures are required.

Gas welding, however, is more transportable and much more versatile and can be used in other processes apart from just welding itself. It is slower than arc welding but at times will yield finer points. Gas welding is thus best used with lighter materials as well as fieldwork where there is no electrical power.

Also Read: Welding Excellence - Superon 308L Stainless Steel Elecrode